Robin and Darryl, staying in the Mitchell’s Bayview Villa, cut a wide swatch across the Islamorada restaurant scene in the three weeks they stayed with us. Here is Robin’s review of their adventure and their top restaurant was the Sid and Roxy’s Green Turtle Inn.

Phyllis and I think Robin is pretty close to our opinion but we have some differences. What do you think? Let us know.

Here we go.

• Agave Mexican – So! So!
  Bentley’s – Good Ribs
  Debbiy Doo’s – Very large sandwiches, Boars Head meats
  Green Turtle Inn – The Best! Our Fav! Lamb shank, OSSO Bucco, Steaks. Scallops & Parpardelle Pasta, Hearts of Palm salad
  Hungry Tarpon – Seafood angel hair pasta
  Islamorada Fish Company – Not our favorite
  Islamorada Bakery – Muffin tops, Nuevo Ranchero
  Island Grill – Spicy tuna roll, Whole fish!
  Lazy Days – Hogfish Pasta
  Lorelei Restaurant and Cabana Bar – Late night music, Bush Whackers, Frozen drinks
  Mangrove Mike’s – Eggs Benedict
  Ma’s Restaurant – Poor Boy sandwiches, Shrimp or Oyster
  Uncle’s Restaurant – Lamb
  Whale Harbor Inn and Marina – Didn’t like
  Whistle Stop – Burgers and Ruben sandwich
  Ziggie & Mad Dogs – Steak